critique-possible prints for competition...2

[Heather Kallhoff]

Here's another...

[Kirk Voclain]

I think this is a great seller, but not going to do well in comp....

The hand looks awarkward, and judges tend to be OLD FARTS who don't understand why in the world would you not move that hair from her face.

But I sure do bet the girl loved it.

Kirk

[Fred Molesworth]

I"m not a judge, and have never entered competition (yet), but I liked the initial impact when I first saw the photograph.

but I'll leave the recommendations to the judges in the group.

[Kirk Voclain]

THAT,,

Is the very reason there is NOT just one judge on a panel. So we've got one for it, and one against.

Anyone else want to come in and judge this one???

Kirk

[Gary Affleck]

Sorry, agreeing with Kirk on this one, even though his head is disappearing. Something with the hand, it has a strange shape to it and the eye goes to it. Also it's way to hot on the edge of that palm. Good shot though, she'll like it.

[Heather Kallhoff]

I agree with you all on this... I think I was drawn back to it, 'cuz it did sell well. But as we all know, what sells well doesn't normally do well in competition.

This is a tosser for competition. Thanks for your honesty! I will go back to files and see what else there is. Hope ya'll don't mind taking the time to look at them.

thanks again,
Heather